Explaining errors in Star Trek Wiki
Advertisement
According to Memory Alpha's original in Universe Timeline, the story sequence is: Paradise : Whispers : Shadowplay.

Summary

When Chief O'Brien returns from a mission to the Paradas, everyone reacts strangely on him. His wife Keiko avoids intimacy, Bashir calls him for an unscheduled examination, crucial repairs on the station are carried out without him. He has no access to the station's logs for the time after his arrival, and his personal logs have been reviewed by someone else. When Odo returns from Bajor, O'Brien is glad to have a possible ally, but the security chief appears to be part of the conspiracy. When Kira attempts to disable O'Brien with a hypospray, he escapes to a runabout and heads to the Paradan homeworld. Witnessing a meeting of Paradan rebels with his fellow officers, he draws a phaser but is fatally wounded by a guard. Before he dies he learns that he is not the real O'Brien but a replicant who was created by the Paradas to kill someone on a conference to take place on Deep Space 9.

Errors and Explanations

The Nitpickers Guide for Deep Space Nine Trekkers

Plot Oversights

  1. At the beginning of the episode, O'Brien sets a heading of "410 mark 32." According to the Tech Manual, head- ings are set using the degrees of a circle. Since there are 360 degrees in a circle, the first number should be in the range O through 359. Maybe it should have been 41 mark 32 – either that or it was a quick way to get the runabout to complete a full turn, before heading off!
  2. During a voiceover, O'Brien mentions that his birthday is in September. Many nitpickers took exception to this, since Alexander gives his birth date as a star date in New Ground (TNG). Maybe O'Brien's a traditionalist? CdnTim 1654 EST 4 Feb 2021 - particularly likely, since his mother still prepared food from scratch. Also, Alexander is a Klingon (mostly) whose mother travelled to many worlds, while O'Brien is a human, from Earth...it makes sense that he would still think in Earth dates.
  3. Sometimes Security procedures on DS9 just baffle me. O'Brien is on the run. Ops locates him and erects force fields around his position. Unfortunately, they leave a terminal running inside the area defined by the force fields, so O'Brien can escape. Does this make sense? Isn't this like putting an escape artist in stocks and then making sure he has a set of lock-picking tools? It may not have been possible to deactivate the terminal without cutting power to the force fields.
  4. And while were talking about Security procedures, how many times are the Security officers going to forget to check the conduits when someone disappears from a hallway? After Jake notifies Security of his position, O'Brien runs down a hall and jumps in a conduit. Security personnel soon trot by without even giving the conduit a glance. They probably knew he could be too far along the conduit for them to see by the time they get there.

Changed Premises

  1. Several times this episode indicates that DS9 received transmissions from the Paradan System. There is no question that the Paradan System is in the Gamma Quadrant. Yet in Destiny, Sisko and company work with a team of Cardassian scientists to place a communications relay in the Gamma Quadrant. That episode says that the relay will finally make it possible to communicate with the Gamma Quadrant! Perhaps they opened the wormhole, without flyng into it, to allow the transmissions to be made.

Equipment Oddities

  1. Searching for the cause of every-one's strange behavior, O'Brien has the computer scan for signs of telepathy. Somebody upgraded something somewhere in the past years! During Night Terrors (TNG) Troi had to deduce that aliens were trying to com municate with the ship telepathically because the sensors couldn't register telepathic transmissions. The incident shown in Night Terrors may have led to accelerated research in telepathic detection. CdnTim 1656 EST 4 Feb 2021 - as a workaround, Starfleet procedure may be to scan for elevated levels of key neurotransmitters, too.
  2. All that racquetball has improved O'Brien's reflexes. Just after Sisko and company draw phasers on him in Odo's office, O'Brien takes out one Security officer and dodges a phaser blast from another! He was obviously ready for the others to try and shoot at him.
  3. To hide from a pursuing runabout, O'Brien takes his vessel into the magnetic pole of a moon. Sensors soon quit working, and the computer informs O'Brien that he must switch to manual navigation. So...the runabout's computer can't navigate with visual systems when its sensors go dead? The visual sensors may have also been affected.

Continuity and Production Problems

  1. Try this one on for grungy nitpicking. Just before a commercial break, O'Brien makes the dramatic statement, "This was not my Keiko." Coming back from the break, O'Brien asks the computer to play back his last entry, and we hear the line again: "This was not my Keiko." Except...the intonation on "my" is different. It's more elongated the second time. In other words, it was quicker for the creators to have Colm Meany read the line twice than it was to have him read it once and then dub it once! This could be a minor computer fault.

Nit Central

  1. Norman on Wednesday, February 24, 1999 - 3:33 am: Why are Sisko and co. willing to let O'Brien run freely on the station? Wouldn't it be better, for security purposes to hold him in custody and tell him why? dotter31 on Wednesday, May 16, 2007 - 5:47 pm: Without some proof such a detention would be illegal, and O'Brien would not cooperate (as he did not when they did try to hold him)
  2. Why do the crew members seem reluctant to tell the replicant he is a replicant? Do they fear he will suddenly turn violent once the knowledge is known? If so, that would be a great way to confirm he is the replicant, now wouldn't it? Seniram 1) He might not accept it. 2) The knowledge could kill him. 3) It could lead to the real O’Brien being killed. dotter31 on Wednesday, May 16, 2007 - 5:47 pm: If they did, the replicant O'Brien would have asked for proof. They tried to find proof, but (as they said at the end) they were unable to find any evidence to back up what they had been told. If someone told you that you weren't really you, would you simply accept that at face value?
  3. Keith Alan Morgan (Kmorgan) on Monday, September 11, 2000 - 11:18 pm: In the Voyager episode Hunters, Tuvok says that it is a Starfleet requirement that two people are supposed to be on a mission, but O'Brien apparently went to Paradan alone. Did Sisko feel that it was better to endanger O'Brien's life rather than risk a short show? That requirement could have been more strictly enforced because of what happened here.
  4. When O'Brien's flying to warn the Paradan government, why didn't he send a sub-space warning? It could have been intercepted or blocked
  5. CrackedButter on Sunday, December 28, 2003 - 5:45 pm: The Mekong was 7 minutes behind the runabout, but when he comes out of warp they are 2 minutes behind, seconds after leaving warp himself. Shouldn't they still be 7 minutes behind when THEY leave warp as well? Not if they were travelling at a higher warp factor


Deep Space Nine Season 2
The Homecoming I The Circle I The Siege I Invasive Procedures I Cardassians I Melora I Rules of Acquisition I Necessary Evil I Second Sight I Sanctuary I Rivals I The Alternate I Armageddon Game I Whispers I Paradise I Shadowplay I Playing God I Profit and Loss I Blood Oath I The Maquis Part 1 I The Maquis Part 2 I The Wire I Crossover I The Collaborator I Tribunal I The Jem’Hadar