Explaining errors in Star Trek Wiki
Advertisement
In the Temporal Cold War story arc, the story sequence is Storm Front Part 1 : Storm Front Part 2.

Summary

Previously

In the year 1944, the Nazis have conquered parts of the USA with the help of their alien allies from the 29th century, led by Vosk. American resistance forces free Archer, who wakes up in the apartment of Alicia in the Nazi-occupied Brooklyn. Daniels appears on Enterprise, near-death, explaining that the Temporal Cold War has escalated, and that agents are changing history in many centuries. Silik crawls through the ship, attacks Tucker and steals a shuttlepod in which he escapes to New York. In the meantime, Archer, Alicia and her gang meet with one of the aliens. Alicia's friend Sal kills the alien, but not before Archer can get his communicator and contact Enterprise to be beamed up. Tucker and Mayweather, on the other hand, are captured by the Nazis while they are searching for Silik.

Conclusion

Vosk is willing to return Tucker and Mayweather if Archer agrees to meet with him. But back on Enterprise, the alleged Tucker turns out to be Silik. Still, Archer and Silik join in an effort to find Tucker and to destroy a temporal conduit that is intended to bring Vosk back to his century. Alicia and the resistance group help them get into the building. Silik is killed, but Archer can find Tucker just before Enterprise blows up the facility. The ship returns to a 22nd century where everything is normal again.

Errors and Explanations

Nit Central

  1. T`Pooh on Saturday, October 16, 2004 - 10:23 am: If the Enterprise crew can remember that they participated in an altered timeline, can the people on Earth remember it? If not, what makes the difference? What's the difference between altering, and then restoring the timeline, and creating an alternate universe which then persists in parallel? This is probably down to Mr Daniels and his associates, making sure that Archer and his crew have enough information to properly restore the timeline.
  2. brent on Sunday, October 17, 2004 - 12:34 pm: Why didn't the bad guys just use nanotech, robots and automated systems to build what they needed on an asteroid? Because then we wouldn't have had the cool shot of the Enterprise flying over NYC. Rene on Sunday, October 17, 2004 - 4:24 pm: Your comments, Brent, show you didn't not pay attention. They were trying to hide from Daniels' faction. They basically ended up on Earth in the past and didn't have any of that at their disposal.
  3. Wouldn't it have been less trouble if they'd gone back to ancient Europe and used slave labor? The population would be lower but they wouldn't have to worry about fighting off Allied bombers. Rene on Sunday, October 17, 2004 - 4:24 pm: Yes because ancient Europe would have had machines and technology they could use to build a time machine(!)
  4. Trike on Monday, October 18, 2004 - 12:19 am: Archer told Silik the ship's shuttlepods are damaged. As I understand it, Enterprise has only two shuttlepods and one was destroyed in Part I. They probably still had enough spare parts to build a spare.
  5. Trip shattered a light bulb, then used one of the shards to cut through the rope binding his hands. But the bulb was burning when he shattered it, so the glass still should have been too hot to the touch when he picked it up. He's probably willing to put up with that in the hope that the heat from the glass to make it easier to cut the rope!
  6. Trekkerbeth on Monday, October 18, 2004 - 12:19 am: Ok, so the Xindi still obliterated Florida and a great deal of South America - ??? If so, how does it explain that they must be still there when the events of TOS occur. If not, then why would Archer and crew get a big 'welcome home' and for sure the Vulcans would be wondering why T'Pol was dressed as she was. And for sure, everyone on the Enterprise still remembers it. LUIGI NOVI on Monday, October 18, 2004 - 10:33 am: First of all, the Xindi did not “obliterate” Florida, nor a “great deal of South America.” While the destruction was great, it constituted one line that the Probe’s energy beam drew, a mile or so wide, IIRC, and 4,000 km long, from Florida (beginning with the northwest corner of Lake Okeechobee), cut through Cuba, and stopped at Venezuela, which is only in the northern portion of South America. Florida and South America, for the most part, are still intact ...I believe it was made clear on the show that all the Xindi stuff was a clear disruption of the timeline that wasn't supposed to happen. So we can expect this is an alteration to the original timeline that didn't exist for TOS, TNG, etc. meaning ENT changed those shows retroactively. Like the Kelvin timeline, but far less impactful.
  7. Cybermortis on Tuesday, May 13, 2008 - 8:36 am: Nit: So the Aliens decide that they need some special aircraft to help protect them. To this end they fit German aircraft with advanced weapons...and pick the slowest and most obsolescent aircraft in German service? The Stuka was a dive bomber, not a fighter. It was slow and vulnerable to practically every single fighter from 1940 onwards - so much so they were withdrawn from the Battle of Britain in 1940. They were only used on the Russian front in 1941 onwards because the Russian air-force had outdated fighters and was not all that effective. A P-51 would have flow circles around these thing regardless of what weapons they were equipped with. A Fw-190 or Me-109 would have been a better aircraft to have picked. Why did the Aliens not help Germany out by providing them with something more advanced? The Me-262 was the worlds first operational jet fighter, and in service in 1944. I'd have thought that giving the Germans jet engines in 1940 would have allowed the Germans to flatten any opposing air-force quickly. Its not like the Aliens would have had to do much, just look at the jet designs around in 1940 and tell the designers how to alter the design to make it work. This goes with the first nit - if the aliens were going to pick any German aircraft for advancing I'd have expected them to have picked the Me-262. Using the Ju-87 makes sense - it was capable of staying airborne at lower speeds, had better low speed maneuverability and longer flight endurance.
  8. Where do the weapons on the Stuka's get the energy to fire their weapons? Is an internal combustion engine able to throw out that much power? There would brobably be an auxilary power unit for the weapons.
  9. Why have advanced guns for aircraft? Wouldn't guided missiles have been more useful for a bomber? Guns are lighter, easier to use, and be used against nultiple targets.
  10. So, the Enterprise can't outrun a prop-driven aircraft? If Enterprise can produce enough thrust to enter and leave the atmosphere I would expect her to be able to leave even the most advanced propeller driven aircraft in its dust. It is heaily damaged at this point!
  11. John A. Lang (Johnalang) on Wednesday, January 13, 2016 - 9:14 pm: Actually...there's a scary fact about this episode...Hitler DID have SEVERAL plans to attack America.

    1. Put a V-2 Rocket on a U-Boat and launch the missile when it arrived off shore of the USA

    2. The "Amerika-Bomber"...a two-stage missile that would strike a major city on the East Coast.

    R W F Worsley (Notanit) on Saturday, September 15, 2018 - 3:24 pm: Actually John, the Amerika-Bomber was a conventional long range bomber. The two stage missile was, I believe, designated A9/A10.


Enterprise Season 4
Storm Front Part 1 I Storm Front Part 2 I Home I Borderland I Cold Station 12 I The Augments I The Forge I Awakening I Kir'Shara I Daedalus I Observer Effect I Babel One I United I The Aenar I Affliction I Divergence I Bound I In a Mirror, Darkly Part 1 I In a Mirror, Darkly Part 2 I Demons I Terra Prime I These Are the Voyages...
Advertisement