Explaining errors in Star Trek Wiki
According to Memory Alpha's original in Universe Timeline, the story sequence is: Scorpion Part 2 : Nemesis : Rocks and Shoals.


Chakotay's shuttle is shot down during a survey mission to an alien planet. He is rescued from the jungle by the Fourth Vori Defense Contingent led by a man named Brone. The Vori tell him that they are at war with a cruel enemy, the "Krady Beasts". When Chakotay and Namon, one of the Vori, try to find the shuttle, Namon is shot by a Kradin patrol. Chakotay trains the use of Vori weapons with Rafin, a soldier who used to be afraid of the war. Rafin gains more self-confidence. However, he is killed in a Kradin attack, and Chakotay barely escapes. He arrives at a village with Vori civilians. Here, Chakotay befriends a little girl named Karya. Karya asks him to take a message to her brother and Chakotay agrees, although he knows that her brother's whole unit was killed.

The next day, the Kradin attack the village and intend to take the old and weak inhabitants to an extermination camp. The enraged Chakotay assaults the Kradin commandant. He finds himself with Brone in the war zone again and almost shoots a Kradin who identifies himself as Tuvok. In reality, Chakotay was manipulated by the Vori all the time, who created the whole scenario to train new soldiers to hate their enemy, the Kradins.

Once Chakotay is back on Voyager, he is presented with evidence that the Kradin are not necessarily the hate-ridden entities he thought them to be—as Captain Janeway confesses to uncertainty concerning the right and wrong of the conflict—and that it was in fact the Kradin who helped locate the commander and return him to Voyager. As they depart the planet, the Kradin ambassador makes an appearance in sickbay where Chakotay is recuperating. Due to his recent experiences in the Vori simulation, an uncomfortable Chakotay leaves sickbay and privately confers with Captain Janeway about the difficulties in putting aside his hatred for the Kradin. He wishes that it were just as easy to stop hating as it was to start.

Errors and Explanations

Nit Central

  1. Keith Alan Morgan (Kmorgan) on Monday, July 16, 2001 - 4:46 am: If the Creighton know that the Vori have these training centers, then why not destroy the centers? For that matter, since the Vori use aliens in their war, why don't the Creighton just broadcast warnings to any ship which might be approaching the planet to stay away? By LUIGI NOVI on Monday, July 16, 2001 - 11:36 pm: Well, I'm sure the Kradin (spelling from startrek.com) would like to, Keith, much as they'd like to destroy everything else of the Vori that's a threat to them, but we don't know where these centers are. It's like saying, "You know, why didn't the Nazis just try to destroy West Point or Fort Dixx or Parris Island or something?" The centers are presumably located in secured parts of Vori space, perhaps on their homeworld. D.W. March on Thursday, July 04, 2002 - 12:30 am:FYI, with regards to where this training center is, Capt. Janeway does describe it as being "right in the middle of the war zone."
  2. Vicky on Wednesday, July 18, 2001 - 2:17 pm: I don't understand a part of this episode. Can someone clear it up for me? You know at the end when Tuvok beams down, is he done up as a Kradin or is it just what Chakotay is seeing. I don't get it. If he was done up as a Kradin why would Chakotay looking closer change what he sees? Plus, if he is done up as a Kradin, where is the logic of Tuvok asking "Don't you recognise me?" Is that a joke? Blah on Wednesday, July 18, 2001 - 10:01 pm: Obviously, he can't be done up as a Kradin, not only for the reasons you cite, but also because it'd be a dumb thing to do, since Chakotay is being conditioned to hate the Kradin. It has to be the computer program that's using holograms, but then that still doesn't explain why he changes. (Did the Voyager crew or the Kradin mangage to shut off the holograms [at least the character portions of them] at the same time that Tuvok got through to Chakotay?) KAM on Thursday, July 19, 2001 - 2:56 am: I saw it being more psychological. The Vori brainwashing made him see Tuvok as a Kradin. Although since the Vori are only at war with the Kradin & use aliens as soldiers, one wonders why it make its non-Vori soldiers see a non-Kradin as a Kradin? Seems like it could backfire at some point.

Voyager Season 4
Scorpion Part 2 I The Gift I Day of Honor I Nemesis I Revulsion I The Raven I Scientific Method I Year of Hell Part 1 I Year of Hell Part 2 I Random Thoughts I Concerning Flight I Mortal Coil I Waking Moments I Message in a Bottle I Hunters I Prey I Retrospect I The Killing Game Part 1 I The Killing Game Part 2 I Vis à Vis I The Omega Directive I Unforgettable I Living Witness I Demon I One I Hope and Fear