Explaining errors in Star Trek Wiki
Advertisement
According to Memory Alpha's original in Universe Timeline, the story sequence is: Fair Trade : In Purgatory's Shadow : Doctor Bashir, I Presume.
In the Changeling infiltration story arc, the story sequence is Apocalypse Rising : In Purgatory's Shadow : By Inferno's Light.
In the Internment Camp 371 story arc, the story sequence is In Purgatory's Shadow : By Inferno's Light.

Summary

Worf and Garak follow a mysterious message that Garak's mentor Enabran Tain seems to have sent from the Gamma Quadrant. On the far side of the wormhole they run into a Dominion fleet, are captured by the Jem'Hadar and taken to a prisoner camp. In the camp they meet Tain and General Martok, as well as another prisoner: Dr. Bashir, who was kidnapped on his way to a conference and replaced with a Changeling a month ago. Tain is about to die when he finally acknowledges Garak, who promises to escape, as his son. Meanwhile on Deep Space 9, the crew, together with the Bashir Changeling, is working on a plan to seal the wormhole. When the Dominion fleet enters the Alpha Quadrant through the wormhole, the ships surprisingly turn about and head for Cardassia.

Errors and Explanations

EAS

  1. Prisons in Star Trek "traditionally" have lax security. The Jem'Hadar internment camp is no exception. Crawlways with important systems are rather easy to access, there are no weapon fire detectors and there is no audio or video surveillance. It was obviously considered to be unnecessary!

Nit Central

  1. Mark Stanley on Tuesday, March 23, 1999 - 10:24 pm: Is anyone else bothered by the fact that Bashir "...went to bed one night, and woke up here...", and yet is wearing his uniform, not his blue pyjamas? What, did the Dominion bring him a uniform so the other prisoners wouldn't make fun of him? It would actually be kind of funny in a twisted way -- the real Julian Bashir, languishing in a *different* Dominion prison for the rest of his life, wearing his jammies. Spockania on Tuesday, March 23, 1999 - 11:16 pm: Come now. We've seen plenty of scenes where officers sleep in their uniforms. Perhaps Bashir actually got drunk and dozed off in a bar and didn't want to tell that to Worf? Although Bashir in PJs would have been fun... Especially when we met him coming out of solitary.Mark Stanley on Wednesday, March 24, 1999 - 7:54 am: But Bashir *never* sleeps in his uniform! Every time we've seen him asleep, rudely awakened, or preparing for bed he's been in those blue pyjamas. The drunken dozing off in a bar is possible, I suppose, but generally out of character. Of course, we really have no idea how he acts at conferences. Those doctors... rabble rousers, the lot of them! :0) Charles Cabe (Ccabe) on Wednesday, March 24, 1999 - 1:00 pm: Perhaps, the Bashir likes to sleep in his clothes when he travels. I do this when I travel, most of the time. Keith Alan Morgan on Thursday, April 29, 1999 - 7:18 am: Bashir was asleep in his clothes in If Wishes Were Horses. It was a nit in the DS9 Guide.
  2. BrianB on Thursday, April 15, 1999 - 2:09 am: Romulans don't take prisoners. Klingons don't take prisoners. Jem'Hadar don't take prisoners. Whoops, none of the above is true anymore. Doesn't anyone not take prisoners? Dan R. on Thursday, April 15, 1999 - 4:40 pm: Who said Romulans don't take prisoners? They took prisoners off the Enterprise C..one of them being Tasha.… Keith Alan Morgan on Thursday, April 29, 1999 - 7:18 am: Dan R.: Sulu said, "Romulans don't take prisoners." in The Deadly Years. Obviously, he was wrong. BrianB on Friday, April 30, 1999 - 12:35 am: Thanks Keith for the evidence that it was (at least) once mentioned that Romulans don't take prisoners. That always seems to be the initial premise of every alleged RUTHLESS adversary. I knew I heard it said of the Romulans but did not know which episode. Russ Bindel Rbindel on Friday, June 23, 2000 - 4:00 pm: Actually, a changed premise may not always be accurate. As in the case of Sulu saying that Romulans don't take prisoners, that's not really a fact...more like an opinion. Which can be changes. Spockania on Saturday, June 24, 2000 - 9:34 pm: Sulu may have - indeed, must have - been basing his statement on actions the Romulans took during the Romulan Wars. Back then they didn't want anyone to know what they looked like. Maybe once that didn't matter they started taking prisoners? Keith Alan Morgan (Kmorgan) on Saturday, June 24, 2000 - 10:20 pm: It's possible the Romulans may have taken prisoners, but if none of the prisoners escaped or sent word to Earth (no Federation then) the assumption would be they didn't take prisoners. Also, these were space battles and the only way to take prisoners would be to capture a ship or escape pod, and I don't think they had transporters back then. So capturing living prisoners might have been tough.
  3. Keith Alan Morgan on Thursday, April 29, 1999 - 7:18 am: Major Kira tells Odo that he is still a solid 18 hours a day. Before he was changed to a 'solid' by his people, Odo needed to regenerate every 16 hours. So is this change because of the baby Changeling merging with him? That would make sense - Odo was apparently able to retain his solid form for 18 hours in the very early episodes.
  4. The listening post in the Gamma quadrant tells DS9 that a ship is approaching, but they have to wait until it comes through the Wormhole to know it is the Defiant. Why doesn't the listening post have some kind of ship identification feature? The Federation, Bajorans, Cardassians, Klingons and Romulans are all worried about an invasion from the Gamma quadrant, but no one thought to equip the listening posts with ship recognition abilities? For that matter, why isn't there a Space station on the other side of the Wormhole? It may not be viable to either fit ship identification equipment to the listening post, or to place a station at the Gamma Quadrant end of the wormhole.
  5. Keith Alan Morgan, or is it really a Founder in disguise? on Friday, April 30, 1999 - 4:31 am: If Bashir was wearing his pre-Rapture uniform, then that means the Dr. Bashir who operated on Sisko in The Rapture was really a Founder. Hmmmmmm. If it was a Founder who operated on Sisko, then why wasn't there a medical 'accident' which would eliminate one troublesome enemy captain? Or did the Founder hope to implant something that would make Sisko more amenable to the Founders' wishes? Annonymous no 1 on Friday, April 30, 1999 - 10:21 am: Well, I don't know about you people, but I do think that the Dominion has a much greater chance to win the Federation when someone like Sisko is their representive, then, say, someone like Picard. But then I don't like Sisko much Chris Thomas on Sunday, November 14, 1999 - 1:25 am:Re: "If Bashir was wearing his pre-Rapture uniform, then that means the Dr. Bashir who operated on Sisko in The Rapture was really a Founder." Not necessarily, we've seen evidence of others in Starfleet wearing the old-style uniform even when the new ones have been introduced. Maybe Bashir was damaged his new uniform and all he had was his old one to wear. margie on Monday, November 15, 1999 - 1:26 pm: I know that in the Girl Scouts, once a uniform is official, it stays official, even after new uniforms are created. This way a person doesn't have to constantly buy a new uniform, since it seems they change it every other year! Maybe it's the same way in Starfleet. That would explain away several uniform nits.Ratbat on Tuesday, February 08, 2000 - 7:46 am: I think that Jello-Julian was set up to think bigger than bumping off the station commander (realistically, sure, it'd mess 'em up a bit, but soon enough, they'd have someone else in there - this all from the Dominion's point of view).
  6. inblackestnight on Sunday, March 19, 2006 - 1:48 pm: Did the real Bashir say he was imprisioned for one month or two? Rapture was only four eps before this one so those of you who are good with star dates might be able to figure the uniform nit out. Mrcrusher (Mrcrusher) on Wednesday, November 22, 2006 - 5:04 pm: He said he was captured "over a month ago". That could be 2 months, 3 months or more, so therefore there is no so called "uniform nit", and there never was. LUIGI NOVI (Lnovi) on Thursday, November 23, 2006 - 4:31 pm: Of the episodes between Rapture and this one, Rapture had no stardate, The Darkness and the Light was SD 50416.2, The Begotten had no stardate, For the Uniform was SD 50485.2, and this episode had no stardate.
  7. inblackestnight on Saturday, February 03, 2007 - 1:48 pm: If this nebula supposedly masks JH sensors why not go farther into it once they start coming out? Worf could shoot one of those comm buoys, if runabouts have them, without changing course. Perhaps the nebula also masks the sensors on the runabout, causing the same problems experienced by Reliant and Enterprise in Star Trek II The Wrath of Khan.

Fandom

  1. Firesnowe on Thursday October 3, 2019 - 5:37 Martok says "If you are Worf then you must be Garak." What kind of crazy logic is that? Are Worf and Garek inseparable? He is obviously aware that Worf and Garek are both living on Deep Space Nine - after all, how many Klingons would be travelling with a Cardassian?

Notes

  1. According to the startrek.com episode list, the provisional stardate for this episode is 50526.


Deep Space Nine Season 5
Apocalypse Rising I The Ship I Looking for par'Mach in All the Wrong Places I Nor the Battle to the Strong IThe Assignment I Trials and Tribble-ations I Let He Who Is Without Sin I Things Past I The Ascent I Rapture I The Darkness and the Light I The Begotten I For the Uniform I In Purgatory's Shadow I By Inferno's Light I Doctor Bashir, I Presume I A Simple Investigation I Business as Usual I Ties of Blood and Water I Ferengi Love Songs I Soldiers of the Empire I Children of Time I Blaze of Glory I Empok Nor I In the Cards I Call to Arms
Advertisement